It's all in the writing. After all the structuring is done, the scenes themselves have to shine. Most often, when I read a script, I think to myself, "It needs color." Color the characters; color the scenes; color the dialogue. It's all in the writing.
William Goldman shows how
The Man in Black defeats the Spaniard.
It doesn't sound particularly exciting, and it doesn't have to--it's an outline. Fortunately, Goldman colored those scenes and they are three wonderful scenes that most everyone enjoys.
My personal favorite is "The Battle of the Wits" in the third scene. The Man in Black apparently pours deadly iocane powder into one of two goblets of wine. The scene ends with a lovely twist after Vizzini dies from drinking the wine in the Man in Black's goblet.
The Man in Black starts to lead her off the mountain path into untraveled terrain.
MAN IN BLACK
And with that, he takes off, dragging her behind him.
Not only do movies benefit from an unexpected twist but scenes do, too.
It doesn't matter if the location is boring or typical; it's how you color the scene itself that makes the difference. Let's examine a fairly typical scene from a Western. I think you will find it only moderately interesting.
A typical scene
EXT. TOWN -- DAY
The sun shines on the desert. It reveals the little town. It isthe 1880s.
Near a gallows by the Sheriff's Office is a small crowd. A SHERIFF and a MINISTER are there along with Winslow. The wind is blowing.
POV WINSLOW -- He spots a Pregnant Woman in the crowd. She is about nine months. For just a moment her belly looks bloody.
A crow squawks. Winslow sees the Pregnant Woman is fine and is shaking his head.
The Minister is looking at Winslow.
He holds the Bible in the air and looks up to Heaven.
The Minister nods in the affirmative.
Off screen, the loud creak of a door reveals DEPUTIES exiting the Sheriff's Office with Bradford.
At the gallows, the Deputies halt Bradford by the Minister.
Winslow catches Bradford's eye.
Winslow's thoughts turn to that word "repentance." He thinks about his past.
Bradford interrupts by spitting on the ground. The Deputies drag Bradford up the gallows' steps. He is shouting at Winslow on the way.
The Deputies are putting the noose around Bradford's neck. He gags a little.
The Deputies step aside, one pulls the lever. The trap door releases and Bradford falls. His neck breaks with a crack.
Winslow spots two black suited PINKERTON AGENTS headed for him.
A quick evaluation of the typical scene
Avoid passive verbs (too much use of "is," "are," and other passive verbs). Use active verbs and specific details.
You don't need the words "Off screen" or the camera direction "POV."
Dramatize dramatic moments, such as the hanging. Maybe a bit of humor would help the scene. When I evaluate a script, I often see overwriting. This particular scene is underwritten. It's a key scene that needs more drama and a greater sense of the characters' emotions. [I can say that, having read the entire script.]
You have a crow squawk; maybe it should preside over the scene as a bad-luck symbol. Also, use it for a transition from the vision of the bloody pregnant woman back to scene.
Characterize your characters. Right now, they're rather typical of what we've seen in other movies. You can characterize them by how you describe facial expressions, gestures, and actions. Again, use specific language.
Contrast the sheriff and the minister; emphasize differences. That will help define both. Maybe you can label them more definitively as a characterization tool. For example, what kind of sheriff and what kind of minister? I'm looking for an adjective for each.
At one point, Winslow says, "Is that so?" It might be a good place for him to express his belief that the good he does can never make up for the bad. "Ain't enough" leaves a little room for subtext.
Some of the dialogue is obvious. "I'll see you in Hell" is typical, but could work if there is an original follow-up line or comeback line.
You wrote, "Winslow's thoughts turn to that word 'repentance.' He thinks about his past." Thoughts, insights, and feelings cannot appear on the movie screen. Describe an action or a look that can appear on the movie screen, something that the actor can act.
Coloring the typical scene
Let's see how my client colored his scene, which I'm sure you'll find more entertaining than my "original" above. The best learning will come when you carefully compare the "original" with the 'revision' paragraph by paragraph, speech by speech.
EXT. TOWN -- DAY
A little past sunrise over a desert that surrounds a speck town of early 1880s civilization.
Near a gallows tucked away by the Sheriff's Office, wind kicks up dust around a small crowd.
A ROUGH SHERIFF, a TIMID MINISTER, and Winslow stand in a row at the base of the gallows' steps.
Winslow's gaze drifts to the crowd, lands on a very PREGNANT WOMAN. He fixates on her big belly.
WINSLOW'S TWISTED VISION
Movements slow, sounds dissipate, save for Winslow's hastened breathing.
In a flash, horror grips Winslow. Blood blankets the pregnant woman's belly.
A woman's scream rises. It mutates into a crow's loud squawk.
BACK TO SCENE
A crow squawks overhead. Winslow shakes off the demons, sees the very Pregnant Woman is fine, and settles down.
The Timid Minister glances at the gallows -- apprehension and fear pepper his features.
Winslow stares coldly ahead.
The Timid Minister didn't quite catch that.
ROUGH SHERIFF (CONT'D)
The Timid Minister's eyes bulge. The Rough Sheriff laughs.
The loud creak of a door opening draws everyone's attention. Overhead, the perched crow squawks.
Two very YOUNG DEPUTIES exit the Sheriff's Office with Bradford as their shackled and feisty prisoner. He mutters curses under rough escort.
At the gallows, the Deputies halt Bradford by the shaking Timid Minister, who swallows hard.
TIMID MINISTER (O.S.)
Winslow flinches at the word "forgiveness."
TIMID MINISTER (CONT'D)
Bradford hocks a big old loogie onto the Timid Minister's face. The poor man recoils, plummets to his knees, starts barfing.
The crowd is aghast. The Sheriff is amused. The crow squawks.
The Rough Sheriff leans in, slaps Bradford hard. Winslow's calm, but side steps to avoid the hurling.
The Deputies drag Bradford up the gallows' steps. He shouts at Winslow on the way, complete with spittle flying.
Winslow offers subdued agreement.
The Young Deputies wrangle the noose around Bradford's neck and tighten it up good. He gags, restraining his wrathful speech.
The Deputies try to loosen the noose, but fail.
ROUGH SHERIFF CONT'D)
The Deputies step aside, one pulls the lever with a startled yelp. The trap door releases and Bradford falls.
The crowd gasps! Bradford only falls a couple of feet, not enough to snap his neck. He twists, wheezes.
ROUGH SHERIFF CONT'D)
The Deputies gaze upward, exchange uncertain glances.
ROUGH SHERIFF CONT'D)
While the Rough Sheriff enjoys the moment, the Timid Minister rises, wipes his face and mouth. He glimpses Bradford's hangman dance. Eyes bulging, he's down for more vomiting.
Winslow's unshaken, but he sidesteps again to avoid more vomit. He spots two black-suited PINKERTON AGENTS traipsing a bee-line for him.
The Rough Sheriff's humor fades when he also glimpses the Pinkertons. He peers at Winslow, who's grown worrisome.
When I first read the above scene, I wanted to read more, and that's because 1) I found myself getting involved with Winslow, 2) the elements of the scene and characters were not typical, 3) there is a twist with the gallows not operating properly, and 4) the writing is good.
It's all in the writing...and in coloring your scenes.